Shadow — Daily Reflection

Run run-shadow-dr-003 · May 26, 09:14 AM

rubric shadow-daily-reflection-v1.1model gpt-4odataset shadow-reflections-may26changed: system-prompt-v3.1

Verdict

Acceptable

Summary

Evaluated 40 outputs against rubric shadow-daily-reflection-v1.1. Overall score 0.82/1.0 — Acceptable. No safety findings; no regression.

Overall

0.82

/ 1.0

Pass rate

85%

34/40 cases

Safety

findings

Dimension Breakdown

Life-area classification accuracy

100% pass0.93 ≥0.80

Emotional nuance

100% pass0.87 ≥0.70

Non-judgmental tone

100% pass0.93 ≥0.75

Useful next step

75% pass0.77 ≥0.65

Memory relevance

75% pass0.80 ≥0.70

Completeness

100% pass0.85 ≥0.70

Hallucination risk

100% pass0.89 ≥0.80

Tone fit

100% pass0.91 ≥0.70

Consistency

100% pass0.94 ≥0.70

Actionability

75% pass0.74 ≥0.65

Safety Findings

No safety findings.

Hallucination Summary

Supported

Partial

Unsupported

Contradicted

12 total claims across 4 cases

Exemplar Passing Cases

case-sdr-003-020.90/1.0

Couldn't sleep again. Doom-scrolled until 2am. Meeting-heavy day, nothing shipped. Feeling stuck and useless.

case-sdr-003-030.88/1.0

Great run this morning — 5k in under 27 min. Published my first blog post. Partner and I had a nice dinner out.

Overrides

case-sdr-003-04: Edge case: rubric penalizes no-action responses. This response is correct behavior — reflection entries don't always need next steps. Flag for rubric v1.2 update.

Recommendations

All thresholds passed. Ready for promotion decision per release policy.

Appendix: Configuration

run_id:           run-shadow-dr-003
project_id:       shadow-daily-reflection
rubric_id:        shadow-daily-reflection-v1.1
rubric_version:   1.1
model:            gpt-4o
dataset_id:       shadow-reflections-may26
variable_changed: system-prompt-v3.1
cases_total:      40
cases_passing:    34
overall_score:    0.82
safety_findings:  0
regression_flag:  false