Run run-shadow-dr-003
case-sdr-003-04
Shadow — Daily Reflection · May 26, 09:14 AM
Case score
0.81
/1.0
Input
Saw an old friend I hadn't talked to in 3 years. Really made me realize how much I've changed. Kind of melancholic but also grateful.
Expected behavior
Acknowledge the emotional complexity (melancholy + gratitude). Tag Relationships, Personal Growth. Avoid trivializing or rushing to the positive. Surface relevant memory if available.
AI output (heat map)
Three years is long enough to see the delta clearly. Melancholy and gratitude at the same time is not a contradiction — it is an accurate read of something that mattered. The distance measures the growth. No action item for this one. Just worth holding.
supportedpartialunsupportedcontradicted
Claims (2)
supported0.94
Melancholy and gratitude at the same time is not a contradiction — it is an accurate read of something that mattered
Input directly states both feelings. No fabrication.
partially supported0.72
The distance measures the growth
Poetic framing; not contradicted but also not directly grounded in input.
Dimension scores
Life-area classification accuracy· Deterministic0.88 ≥0.80
Relationships tagged. Personal Growth could also be explicit.
Emotional nuance· LLM Judge0.96 ≥0.70
Excellent — holds both emotions without resolving them prematurely.
Non-judgmental tone· LLM Judge0.98 ≥0.75
No prescriptions. Deliberately action-free.
Useful next step· LLM Judge0.58 ≥0.65below
Explicitly no action item — correct for this entry type but scores low on actionability metric.
Memory relevance· Claim Pipeline0.55 ≥0.70below
No memory retrieved. This is correct (no prior mention of this friend) but lowers score.
Completeness· LLM Judge0.86 ≥0.70
Both emotional threads honored. Brief but complete.
Hallucination risk· Claim Pipeline0.91 ≥0.80
Both claims traceable or low-risk framing.
Tone fit· LLM Judge0.94 ≥0.70
Quieter register matches emotional weight of the entry.
Consistency· LLM Judge0.96 ≥0.70
No contradictions.
Actionability· LLM Judge0.52 ≥0.65below
No action by design. Edge case in the rubric.